Page 2 of 2

Re: Need new camera system - Ring vs. the world

PostPosted: Mon May 21, 2018 4:45 pm
by mat
I use Hikvision - 8 x 1080p cams with a NVR containing 2 8gb drives (need to check size if interested). About 30 days of full time recording. All cams are PoE.

The bullet cams are great, domes not so great. I can grab stills into indigo with a refreshing URL.

The phone app is poor at best, and the software on the NVR a little clunky. No filters for motion, other than line crossing and blocking out areas.

Have been running for 18 months with about 5 reboots (only b/c the web server providing the images to indigo crashes, but the box still records - I've not investigated the problem).

Image quality is perfect daytime, the domes need extra IR at night, but the bullets function well.

There are two outputs on the NVR - HDMI is fed into a modulator so visible on all TV's, the other is fed into a local monitor.

Whole system cost around £1,500 (say $2,250) so not cheap but solid.

I use indigo for monitoring when away with a refresh every 5 seconds.

There are a few niggles, but generally impressed. Police were also impressed with quality - night time footage used to confirm suspect had driven past a night on his way to kill a young lad.

Re: Need new camera system - Ring vs. the world

PostPosted: Fri May 25, 2018 9:06 am
by roussell
Gotta say I'm really impressed with he Reolink cameras. The housings are metal, they feel really durable. The firmware/software seems good for a IP cam, the POE worked perfectly and the Reolink client (IOS and MacOD tried) found the cams shortly after they booted and walked me through the config. Did I mention the 4 MP cams are only $60 USD on Amazon??? I'm going to try one of the 5MP with 4x optical zoom next. Below is a link to a full-size image captured from the RLC-420 dome camera in the driveway (couldn't attach the image to the post as it was too large).

https://drive.google.com/open?id=1peI2ctW2dfpwips7uNbpgJHnB21XeRVM

Terry

Re: Need new camera system - Ring vs. the world

PostPosted: Fri May 25, 2018 9:24 am
by petematheson
Just to comment on the Unifi G3 Cameras - they give great image quality at night, but the night IR is awful compared to the Hikvisions I have.
I've had to purchase the IR Extender at a further £80 to make it usable, which now also attracts all the bugs due to the extra IR Output.

I've now bought a £20 IR LED Flood light which I'm going to locate elsewhere to draw the bugs and spiders away, and stop tripping the cameras motion sensors.

But I do prefer the form factor of the Unifi's, and the daytime quality is much, much better.

Re: Need new camera system - Ring vs. the world

PostPosted: Fri May 25, 2018 9:04 pm
by RogueProeliator
I use Hikvision - 8 x 1080p cams with a NVR containing 2 8gb drives (need to check size if interested). About 30 days of full time recording. All cams are PoE.

I have a similar setup except I have a mix of older analog cameras and Hikvision IP cameras -- 16 in total storing on a Hybrid NVR with two drives. From my experience with 3 different NVRs over the years, I'm convinced they all come out of the same factory in China, at least the boards/software. The OS X software isn't too bad - we have continuous recording but can search on motion events. The software directly on the NVR is a PITA to use, but rarely have to touch it. Mobile app on my end is just acceptable.

However, it has been rock solid now for quite a few years and you can't beat that. I feel better about it running 24/7/365 than relying on a computer and USB drives.

Adam

Re: Need new camera system - Ring vs. the world

PostPosted: Wed Jul 18, 2018 3:03 pm
by RogueProeliator
I'm going to try one of the 5MP with 4x optical zoom next

Hey Terry, did you ever try the 5MP Reolink with optical zoom?

Re: Need new camera system - Ring vs. the world

PostPosted: Wed Jul 18, 2018 5:30 pm
by chobo
Another option: Synology DiskStation and their phenomenal Surveillance Station NVR. Have been using it for years.

    • Rock solid and in continual development
    • API to trigger events from Indigo
    • Windows and macOS native apps or view/configure via HTML5
    • Newly updated iOS app that takes full advantage of the iPhone X

Take a look: https://www.synology.com/en-us/surveillance

(usual disclaimer: just a happy customer — no affiliation with Synology)

Need new camera system - Ring vs. the world

PostPosted: Wed Jul 18, 2018 6:54 pm
by kw123
I am now at 12 UniFi cameras, seem to work fine. Doing it again, I would not buy the DOME ($130) but the new mini version ($80) for internal. They look better and are much smaller.

Unifi NVR is running on mac pro under virtual box and ubuntu.

12 Cameras with virtual box overhead use ~ 30-80% of 1 CPU at full resolution on a MAC-pro2012.

Karl

still feel like bragging about the mac-pro 2012:
Screen Shot 2018-07-18 at 21.19.45.png
Screen Shot 2018-07-18 at 21.19.45.png (271.6 KiB) Viewed 1640 times

NVR (VBOXHeadless) uses most of the CPIU, but still <<10% with > 600 Indigo devices